I am running short on hours to provide a quality post every week because I have been busy preparing for self-publication, so I have decided to republish a few oldies. Enjoy — especially if you are a word nerd.
From post 77: January 11, 2016
Adverbially Farewell
I am here to present a eulogy to an old and treasured friend, the suffix -ly.
I am also here to point out that my version of English comes from mid-last century, that your version is probably up-to-date, and that the English your grandchildren will speak will be incomprehensible to both of us.
As adversity separates the men from the boys, so the suffix -ly separates the adverbs from the adjectives. At least, it used to.
As a matter of full disclosure, I am not a linguist. I am fascinated by languages, but I haven’t taken the time to learn them. I once spoke two semesters worth of Hindi and I can still embarrass myself in German, but my studies have mostly been as an onlooker. I have read several dozen books purporting to explain linguistics, but books by real linguists make tensor calculus look easy.
Still, I can expound on the really low level stuff.
Two factors are at work in language, position and inflection. Latin was inflectional, not positional. Veni, vidi, vici (I came, I saw, I conquered) could be stated in any word order without losing meaning because the form of each word defines its function.
English is often positional. If we say the boy ate the dog, we assume it was a hot dog because word order tells us who was the eater and who was the eaten. If we said the flic ate the flak, we don’t need a dictionary to know who did the eating. Word position tells us.
But I also said eater and eaten. Here the word itself changes depending on how it functions. In English, that change usually comes as a word ending.
The terms for these concepts are positional grammar and inflectional grammar. English swings both ways. If I say the eater ate the eaten, we all say, “So what?” But if I say the eaten ate the eater, I am speaking nonsense, because inflection is fighting against word order.
It can be complicated, but there is a rule in English that keeps it simple. Adverbs typically end in -ly; adjectives don’t. (Ugly is the exception).
Here are three quick nonsense examples, quickly presented. (Okay, four.)
- “The rapid river flowed rapidly through the canyon.”
- “The beautiful sunset reflected beautifully off the cathedral.”
- “The angry citizen spoke angrily to his Congressman.”
Were these examples too silly? Let me dive deeper (pun intended) into the first example.
The rapid river — rapid is an adjective because it modifies river. It describes an attribute of the river, its speed.
Flowed rapidly — rapidly is an adverb because it modifies flowed. It describes the manner in which the river flowed, and we recognize it instantly by its ending.
Once upon a time and place, say my home state of Oklahoma in 1962, teachers taught this distinction and expected student to know it. Even then, however, only word nerds like me continued to make the distinction after the ink had dried on the final exam.
Apparently anchormen never got the word. Ad men say whatever they want, truth and grammar notwithstanding, so they don’t count.
In 2016 (when I first posted this, and still in 2026), if I hear someone making the -ly distinction between adjective and adverb, my ears perk up because it has become so rare.
I think it is fair to say that Steve Jobs drove the final nail in -ly’s coffin. When he urged us all to “Think different”, he made it official that even smart guys don’t need grammar. Now anyone who puts up a sign reading “Shop local” (instead of “Shop locally”) can say, “If it is good enough for Steve Jobs . . .“
This isn’t actually the rant it appears to be. I will personally continue to fight the battle of the -ly ending, but the war is over, and I know it.
Actually, it probably doesn’t matter. I know what Jobs means from context and word order. Losing the -ly ending probably won’t make any difference in the English language. It is just one of the natural ongoing changes that occur in all languages.
I once said that users of the English language who face change have only one obligation. If the change is stupid, don’t use it. The loss of -ly isn’t stupid . . .
. . . but it still hurts my ears.

